Current:Home > BackNorth Carolina court reverses contempt charge against potential juror who wouldn’t wear mask-LoTradeCoin
North Carolina court reverses contempt charge against potential juror who wouldn’t wear mask
View Date:2024-12-23 23:45:03
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A North Carolina judge wrongly found a potential juror in criminal contempt for refusing to wear a mask in 2022 due to COVID-19, a state appeals court ruled Tuesday.
The three-judge Court of Appeals panel agreed unanimously to reverse the order against Gregory Hahn, saying in part that his actions didn’t interrupt court proceedings. Hahn had received a 24-hour jail sentence from Superior Court Judge Winston Gilchrist in October 2022. He asked that the state’s intermediate-level court hear his case.
The judge in 2022 declared that Hahn had been ordered three times to wear a mask. Gilchrist’s order also found that Hahn “willfully behaved in a contemptuous manner” and his conduct harmed the respect that the court’s authority was due.
According to Tuesday’s opinion, the Harnett County Courthouse at the time was under a mask directive — signed in part by Gilchrist — that said masks were optional in common areas and meeting rooms, but judges had discretion to require masks inside their courtrooms.
Hahn reported for jury duty and was directed to a jury assembly room. When a courthouse worker asked him there to wear a mask, he declined. He was removed from the room and taken to a courtroom where Gilchrist told him about the mask requirement in his courtroom where he’d be a potential juror and in the jury assembly room. Hahn responded that “with all due respect, I will not be wearing a mask, sir.” He was found in contempt after Gilchrist warned him about the potential punishments.
Writing the prevailing opinion, Court of Appeals Judge Michael Stading said the elements of criminal contempt weren’t present in this case. Hahn did not disrupt court, Stading wrote, pointing out that he was not a participant in ongoing proceedings in a courtroom and was respectful to Gilchrist.
The masking directive was also invalid because it came several months after state Supreme Court Chief Justice Paul Newby issued a statewide order revoking all pandemic emergency directives, including those giving discretion to local courts, according to Stading.
Even so, there is nothing sufficient to support findings that Hahn “could have known his discussion with the courthouse employee in the jury assembly room might directly interrupt proceedings or interfere with the court’s order or business,” Stading wrote. Judge April Wood agreed with Stading’s opinion. Judge Jefferson Griffin agreed with the outcome but wrote a separate opinion.
The state Supreme Court could now hear the cause if there are further appeals, but the justices aren’t required to do so.
veryGood! (546)
Related
- Patrick Mahomes Breaks Silence on Frustrating Robbery Amid Ongoing Investigation
- Firefighters extinguish small Maui wildfire that broke out during wind warning
- Teachers confront misinformation on social media as they teach about Israel and Gaza
- Sweden appeals the acquittal of a Russian-born businessman who was accused of spying for Moscow
- Judge sets April trial date for Sarah Palin’s libel claim against The New York Times
- Liverpool striker Luis Díaz and his father are reunited for the 1st time after kidnapping
- Video shows Army veteran stopping suspect from jacking pregnant woman's car at a Florida Starbucks
- Texans LB Denzel Perryman suspended three games after hit on Bengals WR Ja'Marr Chase
- 'Devastation is absolutely heartbreaking' from Southern California wildfire
- Union workers at General Motors appear to have voted down tentative contract deal
Ranking
- As CFP rankings punish SEC teams, do we smell bias against this proud and mighty league?
- Southwest Airlines raises prices on alcohol ahead of the holidays
- Who is Yoshinobu Yamamoto, the Japanese pitching ace bound for MLB next season?
- Finance may be junked from EU climate law, leaked memo shows. Critics say it could be unenforceable
- Tom Brady Admits He Screwed Up as a Dad to Kids With Bridget Moynahan and Gisele Bündchen
- College Football Playoff ranking winners and losers: Texas, Georgia get good news
- A man convicted in the 2006 killing of a Russian journalist wins a pardon after serving in Ukraine
- Satellite photos analyzed by the AP show Israeli forces pushed further into Gaza late last week
Recommendation
-
Shocked South Carolina woman walks into bathroom only to find python behind toilet
-
German union calls on train drivers to strike this week in a rancorous pay dispute
-
Deion Sanders addresses speculation about his future as Colorado football coach
-
Armenian leader snubs summit of Moscow-led security alliance
-
The Daily Money: Mattel's 'Wicked' mistake
-
Republican faction seeks to keep courts from interpreting Ohio’s new abortion rights amendment
-
Finland considers closing border crossings with Russia to stem an increase in asylum-seekers
-
What is December's birthstone? There's more than one. Get to know the colors and symbolism